Oil vs Water Finish

Water and oil based polyurethane each offer good protection

There are many misconceptions of both types of finishes. Water-based and oil-based polyurethane each offer good protection; the biggest difference is in appearance and durability. Polyurethane is the one of the most durable hardwood floor finishes whether oil or water based.

We are bona certified craftman and usually will use Bona finishes. A misconception is that water based is not more durable than oil base. If you use any 2k (mix hardener in with the product) water-based finish it will be much more durable than any oil-based product. More importantly, it will not amber and turn orange over time. That being said, we are trained and experienced in many different products based on the look you want to achieve.

A misconception of a water based finish is that it will not have a nice, rich look like an oil-based finish. With the bona system of finishes we will deliver a rich looking oil-based floor with the durability of water base. We use a bona oil based sealer and then apply the bona traffic hd finish coats. This is an approved and proven system by bona when done properly. Distinguished floors will give you the beauty and richness of an oil based floor finish with the non –ambering, more durable water based finish.

Oil based finish is old technology in our opinion. The most undesirable attribute is the ambering of the finish over time. As you can see from the pictures how much it will change over time. It will get very foggy and loss of any grain or color. That being said, we will do a high quality oil based finish but will educate on its attributes.

Water based finish Pros:

  • Provides a clear finish with low odor. Most importantly, will not amber or turn orange over time.
  • If you love the natural look of maple, apply a water-based (waterborne) polyurethane. Pro tip: They appear milky in the can, but go on clear and remain clear. ...
  • Water-based finishes dry fast — most within a few hours.
  • Cleans up with water too.
Water based finish Cons:
  • 2k finishes must be used with a few hours of mixing catalyst, more waste.
  • Difficult to apply and you must be experienced with not only the finish but the environmental conditions.
  • More expensive than oil base
Oil-Based Polyurethane Pros:
  • Less expensive than water-based polys.
  • Easy to apply.
Oil-Based PolyurethaneCons
  • Will tie up the completed areas overnight or the completion of the job.
  • You’ll have to put up with a strong odor.
  • If recoats are done it can get thick looking
This picture is of an oil based sealer on the left and a water based sealer on the right. As you can see, water based sealers will always give a white wash look and hide the grain.

The following photographs exemplify the ambering at different stages. The lighter color will be the bona system and the orange color is on the original, unsanded side.

Ready to discuss your new floors?

Let us know how we can help.

Request a Quote

Hardwood Floor Finishing & Refinishing Services in Massachusetts and Rhode Island

Distinguished Floors provides professional hardwood floor finishing, polyurethane floor coatings, and hardwood floor refinishing services throughout Greater Boston, Norfolk County, MetroWest Massachusetts, Cape Cod and the Islands, and Rhode Island. Whether you prefer the traditional warmth of oil-based polyurethane or the clear, natural appearance of water-based hardwood floor finishes, our experienced flooring professionals help homeowners select the right finish for their floors, lifestyle, and desired appearance.

Choosing between oil-based and water-based polyurethane is an important decision when refinishing hardwood floors. Oil-based finishes provide a rich, warm appearance but tend to develop an amber tone over time. Modern water-based polyurethane finishes offer excellent durability, faster drying times, lower odor, and greater color clarity. Distinguished Floors is experienced with professional Bona hardwood floor finishing systems, including Bona Traffic HD, a high-performance two-component waterborne polyurethane designed for exceptional wear resistance. We can also combine compatible sealing and finishing products to achieve a warm, rich hardwood appearance without the significant ambering associated with traditional oil-based finishes.

From refinishing worn oak and maple flooring to applying protective polyurethane coatings to newly installed hardwood floors, Distinguished Floors delivers careful surface preparation, professional finish application, and attention to detail. Our goal is to enhance the natural beauty of your wood flooring while providing long-lasting protection against everyday wear. We proudly offer hardwood floor finishing, polyurethane application, and wood floor refinishing services throughout the following Massachusetts communities, as well as Cape Cod and the Islands and Rhode Island.

Bellingham, MA
Boston, MA
Brookline, MA
Canton, MA
Dedham, MA
Dover, MA
Foxboro, MA
Franklin, MA
Holliston, MA
Hopedale, MA
Mansfield, MA
Medfield, MA
Medway, MA
Mendon, MA
Millis, MA
Milton, MA
Natick, MA
Needham, MA
Newton, MA
Norfolk, MA
North Attleboro, MA
Norwood, MA
Plainville, MA
Sharon, MA
Walpole, MA
Wellesley, MA
Weston, MA
Westwood, MA
Wrentham, MA
The Cape and Islands
Rhode Island

Don't see your town listed? Contact Distinguished Floors to discuss your hardwood floor finishing, polyurethane coating, or floor refinishing project and service availability in your area.